Skip to the main content.

Complete Design & Build Solution

Click for Consultation


Renovation and Design

Start building your team today!

What Type of Project*


6 min read

Open Shelving vs. Cabinets: A Comparison of Bathroom Storage Solutions

Open Shelving vs. Cabinets: A Comparison of Bathroom Storage Solutions

Bathroom Storage Showdown: Open Shelving vs. Cabinets

Have you ever felt overwhelmed by the clutter in your bathroom?

Or maybe you've struggled to find that perfect balance between functionality and style when it comes to bathroom storage ideas?

In this post, we'll delve deep into the world of bathroom storage solutions, comparing the pros and cons of open shelving and cabinets.

By the end, you'll have a clear understanding of which option is best for your space, ensuring your bathroom remodeling in Roswell is both stylish and practical.


The Pros of Open Shelving for Bathroom Storage:

Open shelving in a bathroom next to a bathroom vanity


1. Maximizing Small and Awkward Spaces

For residents in the Roswell, GA, area, many homes come with their unique architectural challenges, especially in bathrooms.

These spaces often have unconventional layouts, with corners, alcoves, or under-the-eave spaces that traditional bathroom storage solutions like cabinets might not effectively utilize.

This is where open shelving truly shines.

By fitting shelves into these quirky nooks and crannies, you can transform previously wasted floor space into functional bathroom storage space.

The open design of these shelves ensures the room doesn't feel boxed in.

Along with custom mirrors strategically placed to maximize space, they help preserve that airy, spacious ambiance.

Furthermore, for those looking to elevate their bathroom's aesthetics, recessed niche shelving or built-in shelves are a fantastic option.

Built directly into the wall, these niches provide a seamless look, allowing you to store essentials or decorative items without protruding into the room.

This integration ensures that even in the most compact bathrooms, every square inch is used efficiently, enhancing both functionality and design.


2. Functionality and Aesthetics

A bathroom with a vanity cabinet and open shelving built in to the wall

Open shelving seamlessly blends practicality with design, making it a popular choice for homeowners who want both functionality and aesthetics in their bathrooms.

Unlike closed cabinets that hide items away, open shelves proudly display them, turning even everyday essentials into decorative elements.

Imagine a neatly folded stack of plush towels, a vase of fresh flowers, or a collection of artisanal soaps and bath salts – they all become part of the room's decor.

This open concept encourages homeowners to curate their items, ensuring only the most beautiful or functional pieces are on display in their bathroom storage space.

For those who love to frequently change up their decor or who enjoy seasonal styling, open shelves make it easy to swap out items, keeping the bathroom look fresh and updated.

And if you're thinking outside the box, incorporating unconventional bathroom storage solutions like rustic ladders can add a bohemian flair, while chic tables or carts can infuse a touch of elegance, making the bathroom uniquely yours.


3. Cost-Effective

In today's world, where every dollar counts, finding cost-effective solutions for home improvements is paramount.

Open shelving emerges as a clear winner when it comes to cost.

Traditional cabinetry, with its intricate designs, hardware, and often custom measurements, can quickly escalate in cost.

In contrast, open shelves, made from a variety of materials ranging from wood to metal, offer a more budget-friendly alternative if you are concerned about budgeting for bathroom remodeling.

Additionally, the installation process for open shelving is typically more straightforward.

There's no need for complex fittings or alignments that cabinets often demand.

This DIY-friendly nature of open shelves means homeowners can often tackle the installation themselves, eliminating the need for professional labor costs.

So, for those in search of a bathroom storage solution that's both stylish and economical, open shelving is a compelling choice, ensuring you get the most bang for your buck.


The Cons of Open Shelving for Bathroom Storage:

An open shelving unit next to a freestanding tub


1. Exposure to Elements

Open shelving, despite its aesthetic appeal, does come with its set of challenges, especially in environments like the bathroom.

The absence of doors means that everything on the shelf is directly exposed to the fluctuating temperatures and moisture levels typical in bathrooms.

Over time, this can affect the longevity of certain items.

For instance, that pristine roll of toilet paper might absorb moisture, becoming less than ideal for its intended use.

Similarly, beauty and grooming gadgets, along with their cords, are not only visible but also more susceptible to potential damage from water splashes or steam.

This exposure necessitates careful consideration of what to store on these shelves and how to protect them.


2. Maintenance

A bathroom with open shelving by the toilet

Open shelves, while visually appealing, require a consistent upkeep regimen to maintain their allure.

Unlike closed cabinets that can hide a bit of dust or the occasional smudge, every speck is visible on open shelving.

This is particularly true for glass shelves, which, although elegant, can quickly show fingerprints, water splashes, or soap scum.

This means more frequent wipe-downs compared to other materials.

Similarly, items displayed are also exposed to dust, requiring not just the shelves but everything on them to be cleaned regularly.

For those who prioritize low-maintenance solutions, this added cleaning commitment is something to consider.


3. Limited Concealment

Open shelving, by design, puts everything out in the open, which can be a double-edged sword.

While it's great for showcasing beautiful towels or decorative items, it's not ideal for personal products, spare toiletries, or those items we'd rather keep private.

Unlike closed cabinets that offer a hidden sanctuary for such items, open shelves require strategic planning.

This might mean investing in attractive containers or wire baskets to discreetly store items or diligently decluttering to ensure only the essentials are on display.

For those who value privacy or have a plethora of personal items, this lack of concealment can pose a challenge.


The Pros of Cabinets for Bathroom Storage:

A bathroom with multiple bathroom cabinets


1. Protection and Concealment

From the bathroom vanity to the medicine cabinet, cabinets, with their sturdy structure and enclosing doors, serve as the first line of defense in safeguarding our bathroom items.

Bathroom cabinets act as barriers against common bathroom nuisances like steam from hot showers, potential water spillages, or even the occasional splash from the sink.

This ensures that items, whether they're delicate toiletries or electronic devices, remain in optimal condition.

Furthermore, modern cabinets often come equipped with built-in electrical outlets, a feature that's invaluable in today's tech-driven world.

This allows for easy charging or storage of electric toothbrushes, razors, or hair tools, keeping cords tucked away and counters clutter-free.


2. Sleek and Stylish Designs

Custom bathroom storage solutions can include narrow pull out shelves


In the heart of Roswell, GA, where homeowners often seek a blend of tradition and modernity, bathroom cabinets play a pivotal role in setting the room's ambiance.

Cabinets come in a plethora of designs, from minimalist and sleek to ornate and elegant, allowing homeowners to choose a style that resonates with their personal taste.

The color and finish of the cabinetry can set the tone for the entire bathroom, be it a serene white, a bold black, or a calming wood finish.

Moreover, many contemporary cabinets incorporate both drawers and open shelving, giving homeowners the flexibility of concealed bathroom storage space and open display space.

If you opt to get a custom bathroom vanity, you can create tailored bathroom organization solutions, such as a narrow shelf on the bathroom cabinet door or vanity drawers specially built for your bathroom essentials.


3. Option of Glass-Front Cabinets

Glass-front bathroom cabinets strike a perfect balance for those indecisive about fully open or closed storage.

These cabinets, with their transparent fronts, allow homeowners to showcase their decorative items or organized essentials, much like open shelving.

However, the glass barrier offers a layer of protection against moisture and direct contact, ensuring items remain pristine.

An added bonus is the reduced maintenance; while they still need occasional cleaning, they don't accumulate as much dust or debris as fully open shelves, making upkeep a tad easier.


The Cons of Cabinets for Bathroom Storage:

Bathroom cabinets typically take up more space than open shelving


1. Space Consumption:

While cabinets are excellent for storage space, their footprint can be a concern in more compact bathrooms.

Unlike open shelving that has a minimalistic profile, cabinets, especially those with deeper configurations, can protrude into the room, eating up the precious space in your bathroom.

This can make narrow spaces feel even tighter, potentially hindering movement or making the bathroom appear cluttered.

For homeowners with limited space, it's crucial to carefully consider cabinet dimensions and placement to ensure a harmonious and functional layout.


2. Cost and Installation:

Opting for premium or bespoke cabinets means investing in craftsmanship, materials, and design, which naturally comes with a higher price tag.

While these cabinets promise durability and a tailored fit, they also necessitate precise installation.

This often goes beyond a DIY project and requires hiring skilled professionals.

Such expertise ensures the cabinets are securely mounted and aligned, but it also means additional labor costs, which homeowners should factor into their budgeting.


3. Difficulty in Locating Items:

Cabinets, especially deep ones or those packed to capacity, can turn simple searches into frustrating endeavors.

Items can easily get buried behind others, leading to forgotten products or accidental repurchases.

While open shelving offers a visual inventory at a glance, cabinets require more deliberate organization.

Implementing pull-out trays, dividers, or clear containers can help, but it's essential to regularly declutter and reorganize to ensure easy access and avoid those pesky "lost item" moments.



Why Choose Ranney Blair Weidmann for Your Bathroom Storage Needs?

A high-quality cabinet in a master bathroom


By now, you should have a clearer picture of the benefits of both open shelving and cabinets.

Whether you're leaning towards the airy feel of open shelves or the sleek protection of cabinets, one thing's for sure: your bathroom's storage space is crucial.

At Ranney Blair Weidmann, we understand the unique needs of the Roswell, GA, community.

Our team of experts is here to guide you through your bathroom remodeling journey, ensuring your space is both functional and stylish.

Ready to transform your bathroom?

Fill out our contact form today, or give us a call. We're here to help!

The Pros and Cons of an Open-Concept Kitchen

The Pros and Cons of an Open-Concept Kitchen

Key Points Open-concept kitchens enhance social interaction, natural light, and flexibility, redefining living experiences by merging kitchen,...

What to Consider Before You Upgrade Kitchen Appliances in Roswell, GA

What to Consider Before You Upgrade Kitchen Appliances in Roswell, GA

A Fresh Spin on Kitchen Updates Have you ever found yourself staring at your kitchen appliances, wondering if it's time for an upgrade? Or maybe...

How Much Does It Cost to Upgrade Kitchen Appliances for a Remodel?

How Much Does It Cost to Upgrade Kitchen Appliances for a Remodel?

A Fresh Spin on Kitchen Upgrades Ever felt like your kitchen could use a bit more zest? Or perhaps you've pondered why the heart of the home often...

How Much Do Bathroom Storage Solutions Cost In Atlanta?

11 min read

How Much Do Bathroom Storage Solutions Cost In Atlanta?

The Ultimate Guide to Bathroom Storage Costs in Atlanta Ever wondered how much it would cost to revamp your bathroom storage in Atlanta? Or perhaps...

Read More
7 Smart Bathroom Storage Solutions That Add Space to Your Roswell Home

12 min read

7 Smart Bathroom Storage Solutions That Add Space to Your Roswell Home

Bathing in Space: Smart Storage for Your Roswell Bathroom Ever found yourself tripping over toiletries in your bathroom? Or maybe you're constantly...

Read More
How to Add Privacy and Style with Bathroom Window Treatments in Roswell

12 min read

How to Add Privacy and Style with Bathroom Window Treatments in Roswell

Enhancing Your Bathroom's Appeal: Why Privacy and Style Matter in Roswell Have you ever wondered how to strike the perfect balance between privacy...

Read More